When you're buying a new roof, one of the most significant choices you'll have to make is what kind of shingles to use. In Michigan, where roofs take a beating from endlessly changing seasons, durability is key. Three of the most well-known brands—GAF, CertainTeed, and Atlas—all produce great shingles, but they're not all created equal when it comes to Michigan's extreme weather.
In this guide, we'll pit these industry giants head-to-head on durability, weather resistance, warranties, and overall value. By the time you're done reading, you'll understand why Atlas shingles stand out as the best option for Michigan homeowners who want durable protection and performance.
Michigan citizens have to put up with a long list of weather issues twelve months out of the year. Winters are cold and icy, summers hot and humid. That continuous freeze/thaw cycle causes an enormous amount of damage, making shingles crack, curl, or even lose their valuable granules.
Other than weathering from the elements, Michigan's humid climate also promotes the growth of ugly black streaks of algae. If you've ever noticed a roof with ugly streaks running down the shingles, you know how prevalent the problem is. Sadly, not all shingles are created equal to combat the issue.
Due to these difficulties, homeowners require shingles that:
GAF is North America's largest roofing manufacturer, and their Timberline product line is one of the most widely installed shingles. They provide great value and are easy to find, so they're a contractor's favorite.
CertainTeed is famous for producing some of the heaviest and most durable shingles available. Their Landmark and Landmark Pro series are extremely popular with homeowners who want a premium shingle.
While GAF and CertainTeed both have their strengths, Atlas shingles surpass both in the areas that matter most, especially for homeowners who are battling Michigan's intense climate variances.
One of the biggest advantages of Atlas shingles is that they are larger. Atlas shingles offer greater coverage and adhesion than GAF and CertainTeed, making them more resistant to storms and high winds. This is particularly relevant in Michigan since storms and high winds can loosen or blow off regular-sized shingles.
Another tremendous advantage is Scotchgard™ Protector by 3M included standard in Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingles. It inhibits algae growth and black streaks for the life of the roof. For GAF and CertainTeed, you would need to go with more upscale models to have the same protection, but for Atlas, it is standard.
| Feature | Atlas Pinnacle Pristine | GAF Timberline HDZ | CertainTeed Landmark Pro |
| Shingle Size | Larger, better coverage | Standard | Heavy, harder to install |
| Algae Resistance | Scotchgard™ (Lifetime Protection) | Stainguard Plus (Limited) | Some models have algae resistance, but not all |
| Wind Rating | 130 mph | 130 mph | 110-130 mph |
| Warranty | Lifetime Limited (Easy to claim) | Complicated tiers | Limited Lifetime |
| Cost | Affordable with premium features | Mid-range | Most expensive |
| Installation | Easier due to size and design | Standard | More complex, higher labor costs |
Considering all of these elements, Atlas shingles provide the best balance of everything that you're seeking. Though CertainTeed is a good high-end choice and GAF is affordable, Atlas is the overall best choice for Michigan homeowners.
If you want a roofing system that will withstand Michigan's harshest weather, Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingles are the best option. With their larger size, Scotchgard™ protection, wind resistance, and better warranties, they beat out GAF and CertainTeed at a better cost to you.
For homeowners who desire a longer-lasting, better-looking roof with less maintenance, Atlas is the obvious choice.
If you're in the market for a new roof in Michigan, you need a shingle that will survive every season. We're experts in Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingles at Roofing Army and offer professional installation with lifetime warranties.
Book a free roof inspection at (248) 326-2020. Safeguard your home with the best shingles for Michigan climates. Choose Atlas. Choose Roofing Army.
